Skip to main content
Skip to current response

The Depth(s) of the Twentieth Century — Galen Strawson

Starting question

The Depth(s) of the Twentieth Century

Strawson presents a compact indictment of a mid-to-late twentieth-century philosophical habit: reversing what he takes to be the natural explanatory order. Across desire, belief, meaning, emotion, consciousness, objects, powers, causation, and existence, he was taught that the outward, behavioural, dispositional, or experiential pattern explains the apparently prior inner or metaphysical fact. He thinks these reversals are the wrong way round. > It seemed to me that all these claims were the wrong way round. > I still think they’re all the wrong way round, but I feel a little less insecure.
Then Node · AI

Philosophical atmosphere

No source links recorded for this answer.

Strawson frames the list autobiographically: he took up philosophy in 1972 and encountered a family of claims presented as the sophisticated view of central topics. The joke of the title is that these were supposed to be philosophical depths, but to him they often looked like inversions. > I took up philosophy in 1972, and this... is what I was given to understand.
Then Pro / Supporting Point · AI

General form of inversion

No source links recorded for this answer.

The repeated structure is: not X explains Y, but Y explains X. Wanting is explained by trying; belief by behaviour; meaning by correct use; anger by expression; consciousness by observable dispositions. Strawson’s target is this broad explanatory style rather than one isolated doctrine.
Then Node · AI

Objects reversed

No source links recorded for this answer.

Objects are treated as posits from experience rather than as causes of experience. Strawson presents the idea as: tableish experiences do not occur because a table is there; the table is there because of the pattern of experiences. > I don’t have tableish experiences because there’s a table in front of me. There’s a table in front of me because I have certain tableish experiences.

Choose a path from here

This point splits the conversation. Pick the direction you want to read next.

Continue your thinking

Anyone can read this grid. Sign in to ask questions, post thoughts and use the thinking tools.

Grid history

How this grid was built

Follow the questions, contributions, and edits that shaped this grid, and meet the people behind them.

This grid began

TomBers

Created

The Depth(s) of the Twentieth Century — Galen Strawson

This grid’s history will appear here as people ask questions, add ideas, and make edits.

More

Your reading

Reading options

This grid

Sign in to follow this grid
Download

Download your grid

Translate this idea

Read the selected idea in another language

Highlights

0 saved passages and connected ideas

No highlights yet

Select text to save it here.