how to define succes

Workspace actions
Starting question

how to define succes

Then AI response

What Counts as Success?

No source links recorded for this answer.

“Success” is not a single thing but a family of ideas. How you define it depends on your values, aims, and the standards you accept. Below are concise philosophical perspectives and a short practical method to form your own definition. Philosophical perspectives - Eudaimonic (flourishing): Success = living well and realizing your human capacities (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics). - Hedonic/welfare: Success = maximizing pleasure or well‑being and minimizing suffering (classical utilitarianism; Mill). - Virtue/character: Success = cultivating moral and intellectual virtues and acting rightly (virtue ethics). - Existential/authenticity: Success = choosing freely, taking responsibility, and living authentically in accordance with self‑created meaning (Sartre; Frankl on meaning). - Social/relational: Success = contributing to others and sustaining meaningful relationships (care ethics, capability approach — Sen). Practical way to define your personal success 1. Name core values (e.g., autonomy, connection, mastery, contribution). 2. Translate each value into specific outcomes or capacities (what would it look like if realized?). 3. Choose measurable indicators and time frames (SMART where helpful). 4. Weigh trade‑offs explicitly (which values can be sacrificed, which are non‑negotiable). 5. Revisit and revise periodically; life circumstances change what’s reasonable or desirable. Common pitfalls - Adopting others’ metrics (status, wealth) without reflection. - Narrow short‑term wins that harm long‑term flourishing. - Equating success only with external recognition. Example succinct definitions - “Success = sustained personal growth and contributing to others’ well‑being.” - “Success = meeting my chosen goals while living by my core values.” References (select) - Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics. - John Stuart Mill, Utilitarianism. - Viktor E. Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning. - Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism Is a Humanism. - Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (capability approach). If you want, tell me two values you care about and I’ll help craft a short, personalized definition of success.

Select text to highlight passages.

Then Thought · Participant

Explain: “Success = meeting my chosen goals while living by my core values.”

Select text to highlight passages.

Then AI response

Success as Goals + Values — What That Means

No source links recorded for this answer.

Short formulation “Success = meeting my chosen goals while living by my core values” combines two commitments: (1) being agentic and intentional about what you aim to achieve, and (2) ensuring the means and ends are consistent with what you judge important. It ties accomplishment to integrity and long‑term well‑being rather than to mere outcomes or external markers. Key components - Chosen goals: concrete aims you adopt through your own reflection (career milestones, health targets, relationships, projects). These make success measurable and agent‑directed. Goal theory and practical reason emphasize setting ends you endorse (Aristotle: practical wisdom/phronesis). - Core values: your enduring commitments (honesty, autonomy, compassion, excellence). Values govern how you pursue goals and which goals you accept as legitimate (Kantian respect for persons; virtue ethics on character). - The conjunction: a goal reached by violating your values is a “success” only in a narrow sense (e.g., status or wealth) and may feel hollow or morally problematic. Conversely, following values without concrete aims can lack direction. Real success integrates both. Why this is attractive philosophically - Balances consequentialist and deontological concerns: you care about outcomes but not at any cost (cf. Mill vs. Kant). - Anchors achievement in character and meaning (virtue ethics; Frankl on meaning). - Encourages sustainable flourishing rather than short‑term wins. How to apply it (practical steps) 1. Specify 2–4 core values (e.g., integrity, connection). 2. Translate each into behaviours or constraints (e.g., “I won’t lie to win clients”; “I’ll reserve Sundays for family”). 3. State 1–3 concrete goals and test alignment: would pursuing each goal require breaching any constraint? 4. If conflict arises, decide by hierarchy (non‑negotiables), compromise rules, or revise goals. Use reflective equilibrium: adjust goals or values for coherence. 5. Review periodically and adjust as life circumstances change. Examples - Career promotion + integrity: pursue promotion by improving skills and networking honestly; reject tactics that require deception. - Fitness + relationships: aim to train for a marathon while scheduling workouts that don’t consistently crowd out family time (trade‑offs accepted explicitly). Common pitfalls to avoid - Adopting goals imposed by others without value alignment. - Treating values as merely instrumental (e.g., “I’ll be honest only if it helps my image”). - Ignoring long‑term costs for short‑term measurable wins. Further reading - Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics (practical wisdom, flourishing). - Viktor E. Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning (meaning as guide to goals). - Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (values, capabilities, and choice). If you want, tell me two values you care about and one goal; I’ll show how to test alignment and draft a short personal definition of success.

Select text to highlight passages.

Continue this thread

This path ends here for now.

Share your perspective, offer an example, or ask a follow-up to continue the discussion.

Other paths you could read

Earlier, at What Counts as Success?, the conversation split. If this is not the thread you want, you can switch to one of the other paths below.

User Comment

Explain: Eudaimonic (flourishing): Success = living well and realizing your human capacities (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Hedonic/welfare: Success = maximizing pleasure or well‑being and minimizing suffering (classical utilitarianism; Mill).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Virtue/character: Success = cultivating moral and intellectual virtues and acting rightly (virtue ethics).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Existential/authenticity: Success = choosing freely, taking responsibility, and living authentically in accordance with self‑created meaning (Sartre; Frankl on meaning).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Social/relational: Success = contributing to others and sustaining meaningful relationships (care ethics, capability approach — Sen).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Name core values (e.g., autonomy, connection, mastery, contribution).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Translate each value into specific outcomes or capacities (what would it look like if realized?).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Choose measurable indicators and time frames (SMART where helpful).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Weigh trade‑offs explicitly (which values can be sacrificed, which are non‑negotiable).

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Revisit and revise periodically; life circumstances change what’s reasonable or desirable.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Adopting others’ metrics (status, wealth) without reflection.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Narrow short‑term wins that harm long‑term flourishing.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Equating success only with external recognition.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: “Success = sustained personal growth and contributing to others’ well‑being.”

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: John Stuart Mill, Utilitarianism.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Viktor E. Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism Is a Humanism.

Read this path
User Comment

Explain: Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (capability approach).

Read this path

Highlights

0 saved passages and connected ideas

No highlights yet

Select text to save it here.